As part of assessing the best energy sources for the future, we are looking at the pros and cons of these different energy sources.
This is our guide on Solar Energy Pros and Cons.
Summary – Pros & Cons Of Solar Energy
- Solar is renewable and sustainable (not finite like fossil fuels or potentially uranium)
- Produces no emissions while in operation
- Is a portable form of energy
- Can be used for small applications as well as larger applications
- Can be used off grid
- Can give people energy independence
- Technology is always improving to increase capability
- Demand is increasing, which is dropping prices to manufacture and also buy in some places
- Solar electricity prices for consumers can be more stable than fossil fuel electricity prices which can fluctuate
- Solar requires fairly simple maintenance once up and running compared to nuclear for example (generally cleaning of the panel is all that is required for most smaller units)
- Setup costs can generally be recovered over the life of solar panels
- The typical solar panel has a decent lifespan of around 20 to 25 years
- Solar has the benefit of setting up as many or as little panels as you like – it’s easy to set up in stages or in increments to your liking or needs … compared to a nuclear plant or a coal plant, where you have to set up a whole plant over say 6 to 8 years
- Large scale solar is usually distributed across a wide geographical area, and modular with several individual panel or panel farms. This creates less chance of damage to equipment or disruption to electricity supply in the case of extreme weather or a natural event in one area, compared to a fossil fuel plant that has one power plant in one spot
- Low power output per unit (low power density) compared to nuclear, oil, gas
- Not suited at the moment to large scale (large city size) power supply due to various reasons
- Price per kilowatt can be expensive in some countries, and a setup of many panels can be expensive (but prices are dropping with tech advancements and economies of scale)
- Return on investment can take time
- Needs lots of space/land the more panels you add, unless you are installing them on buildings
- Depends on the sun and can be intermittent
- Not suited to places with little sun
- Solar panels can require scarce materials to make
Solar is a pretty good option for individuals and households at the moment as long as it makes sense financially for them. But, with current solar technology, solar isn’t as suited to large scale power supply for cities as say coal, natural gas and nuclear. Technological advances will hopefully change that in the future, as well as our ability to integrate solar power better into a city’s power supply. At the moment, solar is more of a supplementary power source for the cities that use it, and isn’t as much of a primary source. As long as costs are competitive, and technology keeps advancing to increase power density/power output per unit, solar probably has one of the best long term futures as a power supply a long with wind power.
*Note – the above pros and cons are broad generalisations. Obviously there are different variables to each specific energy project that impact the final pros and cons (like new technology that reduces emissions for coal power plants just as one of many examples). Each energy project and situation (in different countries and cities) should be analysed individually. Having said that, some broad principles and patterns about the pros and cons of different energy sources tend to stay consistent too.
Pros Of Solar Energy
- Is Renewable & Sustainable – not finite like fossil fuels such as coal, oil, and gas. Even nuclear may run out in the next 80 years when uranium is in low supplies. Solar energy is expected to be available for the next 5 billion years.
- Is Clean & Carbon Emission Free While In Operation – produces no carbon dioxide or other greenhouse gases while in use, unlike fossil fuels such as coal, oil, and gas. GHGs are produced in manufacturing solar panels, but these are seen to be negligible when compared to the GHGs emitted by other energy sources. Solar power produces four times more GHGs than nuclear in total (dailymaverick.co.za)
- Can Be Used Off The Grid, & Gives Energy Independence – solar power doesn’t require access to a power grid, so it can generate electricity anywhere panels can be installed, even poorer or less developed countries. It can be used by people free of utility companies.
- Technology Is Improving – better technology means more efficiency. Companies and countries (like Tesla, and Germany who are the world’s solar leaders) are also working on storing excess solar energy in a cheaper way. Quantum physics research and advancements in nanotech also have the potential to greatly increase the power output of solar panels, which could lead to wider-scale use of them across the globe
- Demand Is Increasing, & Prices Are Dropping In Some Places – companies are working to make it more affordable, and higher demand means prices come down to both produce solar energy equipment, and purchase solar power naturally.
- Electricity Price Stability – fossil fuel prices can fluctuate heavily in response to world fossil fuel events and the market. Renewable energy can be much more stable because of stable operating costs. (ucsusa.org)
- Portable, Versatile & Can Be Used For Unique Application – can be used to power street lights, homes, cars, and even small electronic devices, such as your phone. You can get portable solar power panels and chargers. More solar energy uses are coming out as time progresses – making solar very versatile.
- Low Maintenance – compared to energy like nuclear for example. Residential solar panels for example require cleaning once, maybe twice per year. The typical manufacturer’s warranty lasts anywhere from 20 to 25 years. Even though they might have higher upfront costs, you can see how easily recouped they can be over their lifespan.
- Good Life Span – the typical solar panel set up lifespan residentially is around 20-25 years.
- Distribution & Modular Set Up – Solar is usually distributed across a wide geographical area, and modular with several individual panels or panel farms. This creates less chance of damage to equipment or disruption to electricity supply in the case of extreme weather or a natural event in one area, compared to a fossil fuel plant that has one power plant in one spot. Hurricane Sandy has this impact (power loss and damage) on fossil fuel plants in New York and New Jersey, but not as much on renewable energy projects (ucsusa.org)
– renewableresourcescoalition.org, ucsusa.org
Cons Of Solar Energy
- Low Power Output – compared to nuclear, oil, and gas, solar has a much lower power output per unit. Solar is unable right now to provide sufficient energy to power something like a large manufacturing plant with lots of big machinery
- Can Be Expensive – compared to other alternative energies, the price per kilowatt can be expensive, and upfront costs can be expensive (household panels can be $1000’s of dollars). But, costs are gradually dropping.
- Return On Investment Can Take Time – residentially, if you purchase a solar panel set up, it can take years to recoup your cost investment compared to using a utility company for use of their grid-supplied energy.
- Needs A lot Of Space – solar panels that catch solar energy need a lot of space and land to be laid out compared to other forms of energy. The mean power density for solar is about 170 W/m2, much more than other renewable energy sources, but nowhere near the amounts of energy sources such as nuclear. It struggles to compete against alternative energy sources based on its low power density (space to power output ratio). As technology gets better, smaller panels may produce more power per square metre.
- Depends On The Sun & Can Be Intermittent – relies on exposure to and the intensity of the sun. If the sun is not out like at night time or on overcast days or in colder climates, you’re limited in the energy you can catch. This wouldn’t be as much of an issue if there was a cheaper way to store excess solar energy. Intermittent energy isn’t a problem for nuclear or fossil fuels.
- Right Now, It’s Not As Good For Huge Scale Energy Provision – solar isn’t as good to scale for large cities and countries right now as other energy sources. The power output is not there, and existing infrastructure isn’t built around it – meaning you lose captured solar energy that could get fed into the grid (like in countries such as China).
- Solar Panel Cells Require Rarer Materials – Cadmium telluride and copper indium gallium selenide are examples that are not as easily found on earth as coal and fossil fuels.
- Solar requires more construction material than nuclear – Solar requires 18 times, and wind 11 times, the construction materials of nuclear.
– renewableresourcescoalition.org, bettermeetsreality.com, dailymaverick.co.za